Inside the NFL QB battles

August 5, 2009

NFL training camps open with six starting quarterback jobs up for grabs.


Here is a look at each position battle and what each player brings to the table.


>> Cleveland Browns


Derek Anderson


PRO: Has been successful as a starter before, going 10-5 in 2007 with 3,787 yards and 29 touchdowns.


CON: His numbers dropped precipitously last year. Although to be fair, his numbers were actually dropped by Braylon Edwards.


Brady Quinn


PRO: Proved he was a great leader at Notre Dame. Plus, his popped collar only adds to that. It makes him appear regal. Almost like royalty.


CON: Opposing defenses have a tendency to read his eyes. Mainly because they can't take their gaze off of them.


>> Detroit Lions


Daunte Culpepper


PRO: Has put up big numbers and won games in the past before his knee injuries.


CON: Lost of mobility means- … did he just get sacked in a drill without a defense? My God.


Matthew Stafford


PRO: Most scouts rate him a can't-miss.


CON: Most scouts rated Joey Harrington a can't-miss.


>> Minnesota Vikings


Tarvaris Jackson


PRO: Is not Brett Favre.


CON: Is not Brett Favre.


Sage Rosenfels


PRO: Is not Brett Favre.


CON: Is not Brett Favre.


>> New York Jets


Kellen Clemens


PRO: Despite his last name and the fact that his first name starts with a K, he's not related to that dickwad Roger Clemens.


CON: Perhaps not coincidentally, he also can't throw anywhere near as well as Roger Clemens. (But as an addendum to his PRO: he's also not on steroids. So that's nice.)


Mark Sanchez


PRO: Has experience running a pro-style offense and playing under the pressures of a pro-style contract.


CON: He has never played a game in the snow. (And he may never. Please recycle!)


>> San Francisco 49ers


Shaun Hill


PRO: Is a solid game manager.


CON: He manages to lose. A lot.


Alex Smith


PRO: Tied a career high in touchdowns last season and has been a consistent contributor since coming into the league.


CON: Unfortunately, that's Alex Smith the tight end. Alex Smith the quarterback is a pile of crap.


>> Tampa Bay Buccaneers


Josh Freeman


PRO: He rewrote the record books at Kansas State.


CON: I'm just quoting that from something I read elsewhere. I seriously doubt Kansas State has record books.


Byron Leftwich


PRO: Gets his whole team involved. Usually by having them carry him up and down the field when he gets hurt.


CON: Questionable decision making. (He turned down a contract from the reigning Super Bowl champions to play for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers!)


Luke McCown


PRO: Is not Cade McCown or Josh McCown.


CON: Is Luke McCown.



URL Close
Comments ()