All-Stink Team: The Crappiest MLB All-Stars Since 2000

All-Star Game logo

American League

P

James Baldwin, White Sox (2000)
Joe Mays, Twins (2001)
Eric Milton, Twins (2001)
Paul Quantrill, Blue Jays (2001)
Lance Carter, Devil Rays (2003)
Mark Redman, Royals (2006)
George Sherrill, Orioles (2008)
Fausto Carmona, Indians (2010)
Matt Thornton, White Sox (2010)

C

Dioner Navarro, Rays (2008)
John Buck, Blue Jays (2010)

1B

Ken Harvey, Royals (2004)

2B

Jose Lopez, Mariners (2006)

3B
Joe Crede, White Sox (2008)
Ty Wigginton, Orioles (2010)

SS

Mike Bordick, Orioles (2000)
Jason Bartlett, Rays (2009)

OF

Robert Fick, Tigers (2002)
Gary Matthews, Jr., Rangers (2006)
Matt Joyce, Rays (2011)

National League

P

Bob Wickman, Brewers (2000)
Mike Remlinger, Braves (2002)
Shawn Chacon, Rockies (2003)
Dan Kolb, Brewers (2004)
Chad Cordero, Nationals (2005)
Derrick Turnbow, Brewers (2006)
Zach Duke, Pirates (2009)
Matt Capps, Nationals (2010)
Evan Meek, Pirates (2010)
Kevin Correia, Pirates (2011)

C

Damian Miller, Diamondbacks (2002)

1B

Gaby Sanchez, Marlins (2011)
Bryan LaHair, Cubs (2012)

2B

Junior Spivey, Diamondbacks (2002)

3B

Jeff Cirillo, Rockies (2000)

SS

Jack Wilson, Pirates (2004)
Felipe Lopez, Reds (2005)

OF

Aaron Rowand, Phillies (2007)
Ryan Ludwick, Cardinals (2008)
Nate McLouth, Pirates (2008)
Brad Hawpe, Rockies (2009)
Marlon Byrd, Cubs (2010)

Advertisement